When it comes to feeding your baby with an infant formula, cow’s milk infant formulas are generally more recommended over the soy-based ones. However, if for some reason you need to resort to a soy-based infant formula, there are some choices available. Below, we will help you choose between Gerber Good Start Soy vs Enfamil Prosobee.
This article will discuss further about:
– When to use a soy-based infant formula
– The ingredient analysis of Gerber Good Start Soy
– The ingredient analysis of Enfamil Prosobee
– The nutrition of Gerber Good Start Soy vs Enfamil Prosobee
– The available packaging sizes of each product here
– Which soy-based infant formula that is generally better
About Soy-Based Infant Formula
Let’s clear things out first. The best milk for feeding a baby is the mother’s breast milk, as it provides complete nutrition as well as important elements that support the growth, development, and immune system of the baby. However, sometimes breast milk isn’t an option. This is where infant formulas come in.
Infant formulas that are made from cow’s milk are the most recommended. These infant formulas provide the best nutrition. Meanwhile, soy has lower nutrition than cow’s milk, which is why soy-based infant formulas like Isomil Vs ProSobee are reinforced with other ingredients. Soy-based products are not suitable for babies that are born prematurely.
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), as noted by WebMD, about 14% of babies who are allergic to cow’s milk are also allergic to soy. When dealing with allergy problems, it is almost always better to use a hypoallergenic infant formula with hydrolyzed protein.
There are only few scenarios in which you really have to resort to soy-based infant formulas. First, if you prefer a vegetarian diet for your family, you can choose a soy-based infant formula. Such formulas are usually designed to be suitable for vegans and vegetarians. Second, if your baby has lactose intolerance, hereditary lactase deficiency, or galactosemia, you should choose a soy-based infant formula. Babies with such conditions are unable to digest lactose or galactose in cow’s milk.
Ingredients of Gerber Good Start Soy
Now, if you really need to use a soy-based infant formula for your baby, let’s compare the ingredients of Gerber Good Start Soy vs Enfamil Prosbee. Just like the case with any other infant formula, we must take a look at the ingredient list to determine the quality of the product. This is also to avoid other ingredients that may cause allergy reactions as well.
The first ingredients of Gerber Good Start Soy include corn maltodextrin, soy oil, coconut oil, palm olein, high oleic sunflower oil, sucrose, and enzymatically hydrolyzed soy protein isolate. Other ingredients which come in much smaller amounts include M. alpina oil, C. cohnii oil, soy lecithin, inositol, choline chloride, as well as additional vitamins and minerals.
This infant formula is certified to be non-GMO. It does not use any genetically-modified ingredient that may be dangerous for your child. It is also enriched with highly nutritious and beneficial ingredients. The soy protein is hydrolyzed enzymatically, so it should be gentle on the stomach and easy to digest. M. alpina oil and C. cohnii oil are sources of ARA and DHA, which are very important for your baby’s brain development and nerve system.
Unfortunately, the very first ingredient is corn maltodextrin. This ingredient is a sweetener and thickener. It is a source of calories. However, using both corn maltodextrin and sucrose may seem to be a little bit too much especially for an infant formula. Too much sugar.
Ingredients of Enfamil Prosobee
The first ingredients of Enfamil Prosobee are corn syrup solids, soy oil, coconut oil, palm olein, high oleic sunflower oil, soy protein isolate. Other ingredients that come in smaller amounts include M. alpina oil, C. cohnii oil, inositol, choline chloride, and added vitamins and minerals.
Enfamil Prosobee is not certified to be non-GMO. So, if you are really against using genetically-modified ingredients, this is not exactly the best option. Nevertheless, the overall ingredient quality is good, as it uses ingredients that are important and beneficial for your child’s growth and development. There are also sources of ARA and DHA here.
Enfamil Prosobee also lists corn syrup solids as the first ingredient. Corn syrup solids are used to enhance the flavor and thicken the texture. At least, this infant formula does not use additional sucrose, so the sugar level won’t be as high.
Now, we are going to compare the nutrition of Gerber Good Start Soy vs Enfamil Prosobee. In general, Gerber Good Start Soy is better in terms of nutrition because it provides higher amounts of nutrients, vitamins, and minerals. Indeed, the differences are rather marginal; so, in the end, both infant formulas actually provide good nutrition.
Each serving of Gerber Good Start Soy provides 100 calories. From this serving, your baby can get 11.1 grams of carbohydrate, 2.5 grams of protein, 5.1 grams of fat, and 920 mg of linoleic acid.
Each serving of Enfamil Prosobee provides 100 calories. This amount of serving contains 10.6 grams of carbohydrate, 2.5 grams of protein, 5.3 grams of fat, and 800 mg of linoleic acid.
Compared to Enfamil Prosobee, Gerber Good Start Soy indeed has higher carbohydrate (sugar is a type of carbohydrate, after all) and slightly lower fat. However, it is also important to point out that Gerber Good Start Soy provides more linoleic acid. In addition, several vitamins and minerals come in slightly higher amounts. Meanwhile, Enfamil Prosobee is only higher in fat, zinc, and chloride.
Available Packaging Sizes
Gerber Good Start Soy is available in 25.7-oz cans. In addition, it is also available in ready-to-feed liquid in 33.8-fl-oz bottles. The bottles are ideal for traveling and for busy parents who need a practical feeding solution.
Enfamil Prosobee powder is available in 12.9-oz and 22-oz cans. It is also available in liquid concentrate in 13-fl-oz bottles. There are two packaging sizes available for the ready-to-use liquid, which are 2-fl-oz and 8-fl-oz.
Gerber Good Start Soy vs Enfamil Prosobee
|Gerber Good Start Soy||Enfamil Prosobee|
|- Certified to be non-GMO||- May use genetically-modified ingredients|
|- Uses enzymatically hydrolyzed soy protein, easy to digest||- Uses soy protein isolate|
|- Higher carbohydrate content||- Lower carbohydrate content|
|- Higher in linoleic acid as well as most vitamins and minerals||- Slightly higher in fat, zinc, and chloride|
In general, Gerber Good Start Soy is more recommended. There are at least two reasons for this. First, it is certified to be non-GMO. Second, it provides higher nutritional values. It gives slightly better nutrition for your child.