Both Plum Organics and Happy Baby Formula are organic infant formulas made from high-quality ingredients. All of the ingredients are from natural sources. They both are free from artificial colors, flavors, or sweeteners. So, which one is better for your baby? Read the comparison between Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula below to find out.
What we are going to discuss in this article include:
– What ingredients that each organic infant formula uses
– The nutritional enhancements in each formula
– The comparison of the nutritional values of the two formulas
– What potential issues that you need to avoid on each formula
– The packaging sizes of Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula
– Which organic infant formula that is more recommended
Plum Organic: Ingredients
Plum Organics is a company that produces organic foods. They believe that the nature’s complex built-in nutrition is the best way to nourish your baby. In other words, breast milk is the best. But they know that sometimes a mother can’t provide breast milk for her baby due to some reasons. So, they try to make the best organic infant formula that can help you give the best nutrition for your baby. See also: Prosobee vs Nutramigen.
The primary ingredients of the Plum Organics infant formula are organic lactose, organic plant-based oils, and organic nonfat milk and whey protein. Note that the lactose, nonfat milk, and whey protein are acquired from cow’s milk. Science has proven that, besides breast milk, cow’s milk is the type of milk with the highest nutrition. It is enriched with plant-based oils, vitamins, and minerals to provide complete nutrition for your baby.
Plum Organics uses palm oil, coconut oil, high oleic sunflower oil, and soy oil. So, keep in mind that this infant formula uses both cow’s milk and soy – two natural ingredients that are generally safe and healthy, but may cause allergy problems on some babies. This infant formula does not use any artificial ingredient or genetically engineered ingredient.
Actually, Plum Organic is available in two versions, Premium and Gentle. The explanation above is for the Premium Formula. If your baby has an allergy to cow’s milk or soy, you should choose the Gentle Formula, which uses partially hydrolyzed protein to allow easy digestion. Both the Premium Formula and the Gentle Formula are kosher and gluten-free.
Happy Baby Formula: Ingredients
Happy Baby Formula also acknowledges that, although breastfeeding can give the ideal nutrition for your baby, breastfeeding is not always a viable option. Happy Baby Formula offers to help with complete nutrition for your baby. It comes with key vitamins and minerals that are typically found in breast milk, while being free from artificial or genetically engineered ingredients.
The main ingredients of Happy Baby Formula are lactose, DHA/ARA, protein, prebiotics, vitamins, and minerals. The lactose and protein are acquired mostly from cow’s milk, but the other ingredients are similar. This infant formula also uses plant-based oils including palm oil, soy oil, coconut oil, and high oleic sunflower oil. The prebiotic mix includes GOS and FOS, which can mimic breast milk’s prebiotics in supporting your baby’s digestive health and immune system.
Just like Plum Organics, Happy Baby Formula is available in several versions. The Stage 1 Formula is for babies between 0 – 12 months, while the Stage 2 Formula is for babies from at least 6 months old. There is the Stage 1 Sensitive Formula, which has a reduced lactose content, designed for babies with fussiness due to lactose intolerance.
In terms of nutritional enhancements, Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula are similar to a certain degree. Both infant formulas are modeled to be as similar as possible to breast milk. However, there are subtle yet important differences.
Both Plum Organics and Happy Baby Formula are enriched with DHA and ARA. These nutrients are very important for babies. These nutrients are needed for brain and eye development.
The difference is that Plum Organics doesn’t contain probiotics, while Happy Baby Formula comes with probiotics. As mentioned above, probiotics are beneficial for your baby’s digestive health and immune system.
So, how is the nutrition of Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula? For sure, both infant formulas provide complete vitamins and minerals. The amounts of vitamins and minerals are mostly comparable. Their nutritional profiles are balanced.
Each 150mL serving of Plum Organics with normal dilution provides about 100 calories. It contains 10.4 grams carbohydrate, 5.63 grams fat, 2.07 grams protein, 133 grams of water, and 750 mg linoleic acid.
Meanwhile, each 150mL serving of Happy Baby Formula also provides about 100 calories. This serving contains 12 grams carbohydrate, 5.1 grams fat, 2.07 grams protein, 133 grams water, and 750 mg linoleic acid.
Plum Organics Premium Formula contains cow’s milk and soy, so it is not recommended if your baby has lactose intolerance, cow’s milk allergy, or soy allergy. A viable alternative is Plum Organics Gentle Formula, which uses partially hydrolyzed protein so that it won’t cause allergy problems.
Happy Baby Formula may also cause allergy problems due to the cow’s milk and soy. If your baby has lactose intolerance, you can choose the Stage 1 Sensitive Formula. However, if your baby is allergic to cow’s milk or soy, you need to choose a different product, as Happy Baby Formula does not have any variant that uses partially hydrolyzed protein.
Available Packaging Sizes
Plum Organics is available in two packaging sizes, 21-oz tubs and 32-oz tubs. There are also pack-of-four bundles for parents who want to keep a long-term supply. You can choose the smaller tub to try it first. The larger tub is ideal when you are already certain that the formula is suitable for your baby.
Happy Baby Formula is only available in one packaging size, which is 21-oz. But you can buy it in a bundle of four. Just choose the single package to try it first. You can choose the bundle of four for a long-term supply.
Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula
|Plum Organics||Happy Baby Formula|
|- Has a Gentle Formula for babies with allergy||- Has a Sensitive Formula for babies with lactose intolerance|
|- Doesn’t have prebiotics||- Comes with prebiotics|
|- Lower carbohydrate and higher fat||- Higher carbohydrate and lower fat|
|- Available in 21-oz and 32-oz tubs||- Only available in 21-oz tubs|
Both are good organic infant formulas, but Plum Organics is slightly better because it has Premium Formula and Gentle Formula. While the Premium Formula is suitable for most babies, the Gentle Formula is especially great for babies who are allergic to cow’s milk or soy. It is also available in more packaging sizes.