Below, you can read the comparison between two organic infant formulas, which are Plum Organics vs Honest Company Formula. These organic infant formulas are free from artificial ingredients. The following article will show you the differences in their ingredients, nutritional values, and enhancements so that you can determine the best one for your baby.
Continue reading below to find out further about:
– The ingredients of each organic infant formula
– The enhancements on each product
– The nutrition of Plum Organics vs Honest Company Formula
– The available packaging size on each product
– Which organic infant formula that is more recommended
Ingredients of Plum Organics
As usual, we start by comparing the ingredients of these infant formulas. The Plum Organics company is known to produce organic foods, so their infant formula products are organic, too. They claims that natural nutrition is the best, so when breast milk isn’t an option, you should stick with an organic infant formula. See also: Plum Organics vs Happy Baby Formula.
Just like other so-called organic infant formulas, Plum Organics clearly label each and every ingredient that is organic. The first ingredients include organic lactose, organic nonfat milk, whey protein, and organic plant-based oils. As a note, the first three ingredients are acquired from cow’s milk, which is great. Excluding breast milk, cow’s milk has the highest nutritional values. But this also means that the Plum Organics infant formula is not suitable for babies with cow’s milk allergy or lactose intolerance.
The plant-based oils consist of soy oil, coconut oil, palm oil, and high oleic sunflower oil. These ingredients are almost always found in most infant formulas because they provide essential nutrients. However, this also means that the Plum Organics infant formula should not be given to babies who are allergic to soy.
Even so, note that Plum Organics is actually available in two different versions, Premium and Gentle. The ‘regular’ formula is the one called Premium – this is the one that contains cow’s milk and soy. The Gentle formula uses partially hydrolyzed protein in order to allow easy digestion, and is suitable for babies with allergy problems. Both versions are non-GMO, gluten-free, and kosher.
Ingredients of Honest Company Formula
Similarly, the ingredient list of Plum Organics vs Honest Company Formula also specifically labels every organic component. This is a good thing in a sense that it assures you that the ingredients are organic. However, this excessive labeling may also make you wonder whether the unlabeled ingredients are organic or synthetic. Nevertheless, the product is already certified to be organic and non-GMO.
The first ingredients of Honest Company Formula include organic nonfat milk, organic lactose, organic whey protein concentrate, organic palm oil, organic coconut oil, organic soy oil, and organic high oleic sunflower oil. As you can see, the ingredients are very similar to the ones used by Plum Organics. So, we can also say that the overall ingredient quality of Honest Company Formula is good.
Just like the case with Plum Organics, Honest Company Formula uses cow’s milk as the source of the lactose, nonfat milk, and whey protein concentrate. So, the nutrition is generally good. However, it is not suitable for babies with cow’s milk allergy, lactase deficiency, or galactosemia.
Also, as you can see from the ingredient list, Honest Company Formula contains soy. The plant-based oils provide essential nutrients that are needed by your baby. However, this also means that the organic infant formula is not suitable for babies who are allergic to soy.
One important difference between Plum Organics vs Honest Company Formula is the nutritional enhancements. They have taken very different approaches here. Each of them has distinctive advantages and disadvantages, but Plum Organics is generally better than Honest Company Formula.
Plum Organics is enriched with crypthecodinium cohnii oil and mortierella alpina oil. These are great sources of DHA and ARA. You probably have heard a lot about DHA and ARA from other infant formulas, but what are they exactly? DHA is an important nutrient for brain and eye development. Meanwhile, ARA is needed for brain and nerve system health. So, by providing DHA and ARA to your baby, you can support his or her growth better.
Unfortunately, Plum Organics doesn’t have prebiotics. Prebiotics are used for maintaining digestive health by promoting the growth of beneficial bacteria (which are called probiotics). In turn, the beneficial bacteria prevent harmful bacteria from growing and causing health problems.
Honest Company Formula states that it doesn’t use any added DHA and ARA. This is actually a disadvantage because DHA and ARA have been extensively studied and are known to be highly beneficial for babies. But Honest Company Formula does contain prebiotics in the form of fructooligosaccharide, so it can support your baby’s digestive health.
One serving of Plum Organics in normal dilution has a volume of 150mL (5 fl oz). It provides 100 calories. This amount of serving contains 10.4 grams of carbohydrate, 5.63 grams of fat, 2.07 grams of protein, and 750 mg of linoleic acid.
One serving of Honest Company Formula in normal dilution also has a similar volume and provides a similar caloric count. However, the nutritional values slightly differ. It contains 10.6 grams of carbohydrate, 5.3 grams of fat, 2.2 grams of protein, and 750mg of linoleic acid.
The differences in those values are rather marginal. They both provide good nutrition. Most of the vitamins and minerals are similar. But Plum Organics has a slightly lower amount of inositol, which is 4.7mg. Honest Company Formula is slightly higher in inositol, which is 6mg. Inositol is a vitamin-like substance that supports brain health and development. Again, the difference in inositol content is rather marginal.
Available Packaging Sizes
Plum Organics has two packaging sizes. There are 21-oz tubs, which are ideal for first-time users who want to try the formula first. There are also 32-oz tubs, which are great for a long-term supply. You can also get it in a four-tub bundle, which will cost you less money than if you buy the tubs individually.
Honest Company Formula is only available in 21-oz tubs. But there are two-tube and four-tub bundles available if you want to get a long-term supply.
Plum Organics vs Honest Company Formula
|Plum Organics||Honest Company Formula|
|- Enriched with DHA and ARA to support the brain and eyes||- Doesn’t have DHA and ARA|
|- No prebiotics||- Has probiotics to support digestive health|
|- Slightly higher fat||- Slightly higher carbohydrate and protein|
|- Available in 21-oz and 32-oz tubs||- Only available in 21-oz tubs|
In general, Plum Organics is more recommended. This infant formula provides better nutrition, as it comes with DHA and ARA. It has excellent ingredient quality, and is certified to be non-GMO, gluten-free, and kosher.